In Virgin River, the character Brie Sheridan has been at the centre of one of the series’ most talked-about romantic arcs — notably her evolving relationship with Brady and the emotional ups and downs that come with it. Actress Zibby Allen, who brings Brie to life, has offered insight into why the show’s creators chose to keep her love story messy and real, rather than neatly packaged.

According to Allen, one of the strengths of Virgin River is its willingness to embrace emotional complexity. Rather than giving viewers a tidy romance with clearly defined stages and predictable outcomes, the series allows Brie and her partners to navigate the ambiguity, miscommunication and internal conflicts that characterize modern relationships. This approach resonates with audiences because it mirrors the messiness of real-life love — where feelings, timing and personal struggles don’t always line up perfectly.

Allen suggests that part of what makes Brie’s story compelling is that it doesn’t shy away from imperfections. Characters make mistakes, step back when they should step forward, and confront fears rather than glossing over them. These imperfections create tension and depth, making the emotional stakes feel more authentic rather than contrived for dramatic effect.

Another aspect of keeping Brie’s journey “messy” involves exploring her growth as a person separate from her romantic interests. Rather than defining her solely by who she loves, the storytelling highlights her internal evolution — how her priorities shift, how she reassesses her needs and how she learns from both heartbreak and connection. This adds layers to Brie’s arc that go beyond conventional soap-style romance, making her character development meaningful on its own terms.

Allen also notes that the show’s ensemble nature allows Brie’s story to intersect with other characters in emotionally rich ways, creating a tapestry of relationships that influence and reflect on one another. These interconnected narratives reinforce the idea that love isn’t an isolated experience but a thread woven into a broader community of people with their own hopes, flaws and journeys.

In keeping Brie’s love life messy and real, Virgin River honors the truth that relationships are rarely straightforward. By depicting love with all its bumps, uncertainties and unexpected turns, the series offers viewers a relatable and emotionally resonant experience — one that embraces life’s complexity rather than ignoring it.