‘Chicago Fire’ Star David Eigenberg Opens Up About Herrmann’s “Bad Fire” and Personal Breakdown
The Chicago Fire family is about to face one of its most emotional episodes of the season, and at the center of it all is Christopher Herrmann (David Eigenberg). The upcoming episode, airing Wednesday, October 22, thrusts the veteran firefighter into his worst nightmare — a blaze engulfing his own home, with fears that one of his children may be trapped inside.
In a revealing interview, Eigenberg spoke about the episode’s intensity, Herrmann’s emotional unraveling, and how the rest of Firehouse 51 rallies around him when tragedy strikes close to home.
“Let’s Go”: Herrmann’s Family on Fire
From the very first moment, the episode is pure adrenaline. Herrmann’s house is burning, and his fatherly instincts take over before his firefighter training can catch up.
“It’s obviously a mix,” Eigenberg explained. “It’s family first, but there’s still that trained instinct kicking in. Usually we pull up to a call, get the info, and get to work — but this time, it’s ‘mask on, helmet, go straight at it.’”
The fire itself, he teased, isn’t just physically devastating — it’s emotionally loaded. The cause remains a mystery through much of the episode, with hints that Herrmann himself may have played an unintentional role.
“It gets tied into Herrmann a bit and what happened,” Eigenberg said. “Was he responsible for it? That’s another awful feeling.”
A “Bad Fire” and the Fight to Stay in Control
This isn’t just another call for Firehouse 51 — it’s personal. And when a child is involved, the emotional stakes skyrocket.
“There’s good fires and bad fires,” Eigenberg reflected. “This is a bad fire because we’re trying to locate a young person. Every life matters, but when it’s a kid, it amps everything up.”
With his daughter potentially inside, Herrmann’s composure begins to crack. The team must not only battle the flames, but also keep their friend from making a fatal mistake.
Isolation, Guilt, and Self-Blame
In the aftermath, Herrmann’s greatest battle isn’t with the fire — it’s with himself.
“He isolates himself a little bit,” Eigenberg said. “He’s brutalizing himself emotionally, asking, ‘What did I do? What didn’t I do?’”
While Chicago Fire often highlights the tight-knit support of Firehouse 51, Herrmann’s grief takes him down a darker path. Instead of seeking comfort, he blames himself and pushes away the very people trying to help.
“We don’t need more victims right now,” Eigenberg added. “Herrmann’s the kind of guy who turns inward and beats himself up rather than blaming anyone else.”
“A Warm Prickly” Friendship with Mouch
One saving grace is Herrmann’s bond with Mouch (Christian Stolte). Their brotherhood — often the emotional core of the show — takes on a rougher edge this time.
“It’s not a warm fuzzy, it’s a warm prickly,” Eigenberg joked. “Herrmann’s a little tough on Mouch, but if anyone can reach him, it’s Mouch. We’re dear friends in real life, and that shows.”

A Family’s Reckoning
Herrmann’s guilt extends to his family, too. In true Chicago Fire fashion, the episode explores how one man’s devotion to his work can collide with his responsibilities at home.
“Firefighters put life in front of their own,” Eigenberg said. “But when it’s your own family, it changes everything. He’s dealing with that sense of failure, even though he’s doing what he’s trained to do — save lives.”
A Poignant, Personal Chapter for Herrmann
With real flames used in production and emotionally charged performances, the episode promises to be one of the most gripping hours of Chicago Fire Season 14.
It’s not just about survival — it’s about what happens after. When the smoke clears, Herrmann will have to confront the cost of being both a firefighter and a father.