Emmerdale viewers were left reeling during the September 25 episode, as Caleb Miligan unearthed Anthony Fox’s supposed body—but many fans are already doubting the shocking discovery.

---

Caleb’s Risky Bargain with John

After John Sugden forced Caleb into smuggling him out of the country, the killer handed over one final bargaining chip: the location of Anthony’s body. Caleb, desperate to protect Ruby and his family from prison, agreed to the deal.

In exchange, John deleted a damning email that was set to expose the truth about Anthony’s death. With the note in hand, Caleb set out to dig up the body, finally ending the months-long mystery.

---

The Body Is Found—But Is It Really Anthony?

Caleb later returned to the Woolpack, confirming to Cain, Moira, and the rest of the family that John’s information had been accurate. He claimed the remains he uncovered were Anthony’s, insisting that John had kept his promise.

But viewers aren’t convinced. Many took to social media to suggest that John—known for his mind games—may have tricked Caleb once again.

• One fan wrote: “It won’t be Anthony’s body—it’ll be someone else’s.”

• Another added: “Knowing John, that’s probably someone else’s body.”

• A third echoed: “Oh come on—that is seriously not Anthony’s body that’s buried there!”

---

Could John Still Be Playing Games?

Anthony’s murder has haunted the Dingles for months, and Ruby’s role in his death remains a dangerous secret. If the body Caleb discovered isn’t Anthony’s, John may still have the upper hand—even from afar.

With Cain still plotting revenge and Jai’s blackmail threat looming over Caleb, the family’s nightmare may be far from over.

---

What Happens Next?

If fan theories prove true, Caleb may have walked straight into another one of John’s cruel traps. The question now is whether the Dingles have really gained closure—or if Anthony’s body is still out there, waiting to be found.