Emmerdale Fans Divided Over Gabby and Vinny’s Future — Are They Doomed or Destined to Last?
Secrets, Strain, and Second Thoughts
Emmerdale’s young couple Gabby Thomas and Vinny Dingle are finding themselves in deep waters as secrets, doubts, and past mistakes threaten to destroy their engagement. What once looked like an unexpected love story between two fan-favourite characters is now sparking heated debate across social media.
After their recent storylines took dramatic turns, fans took to Reddit to share their changing views — and it seems opinion is split right down the middle.
Gabby and Vinny’s Hidden Truths
While Gabby and Vinny appeared solid at first, both have been hiding major secrets that could end their relationship for good.
For Vinny, lingering questions about his sexuality have left him confused and distant. Things grew worse when a man named Mike attacked and threatened to expose him. In the midst of his emotional turmoil, Vinny even tried to kiss Kammy, deepening the cracks in his engagement.
Meanwhile, Gabby has her own secret — a one-night stand in Portugal before the wedding, something she’s desperate to keep hidden. With both partners lying to each other, the relationship is built on shaky ground, and viewers can feel it.
Fans Speak Out: “They’ve Lost Their Spark”
On Reddit, Emmerdale watchers voiced their frustration over how the writers have handled Gabby and Vinny’s romance.
One fan wrote:
“I used to love them! Gabby helped Vinny gain confidence, and he brought out her softer side. But now, the drama feels forced — they’ve lost the spark that made them interesting.”
Another viewer disagreed, arguing that the tension keeps the storyline compelling:
“This is what soaps do best — relationship drama! Cheating and secrets always make for more twists. I’m not a fan of breakups, but it’s realistic.”
Some fans, however, think the pair are too mismatched to work:
“They’re so different now. I don’t see any chemistry anymore. Vinny and Kammy actually make a better match.”
Can Gabby and Vinny Survive the Truth?
Despite the backlash, some loyal fans are still rooting for the couple — but with one condition: honesty. Many viewers say they’d love to see Gabby and Vinny finally sit down and have an open conversation about everything that’s been festering between them.
Whether that happens or not, Emmerdale is clearly setting the stage for heartbreak. With Vinny’s secret court case and Gabby’s guilt still looming, the couple’s future on the Dales looks uncertain at best.