The cowboy life has always been a dangerous one on Yellowstone. Season 5 has proven especially deadly, claiming John Dutton and Sarah Atwood before shocking fans with the death of Colby Mayfield—a loyal ranch hand and one of the show’s most grounded characters. Unlike John and Sarah, Colby wasn’t a power player or schemer. His death hit differently, raising questions about why the series chose to take him out now.

---

What Happened to Colby in Season 5, Episode 12

In the episode “Counting Coup,” a tragic accident sealed Colby’s fate. When Carter tried to tend to a notoriously dangerous horse, things turned chaotic. As the young boy found himself cornered, Colby rushed in to protect him.

The rescue cost him his life. The horse kicked Colby in the chest, killing him instantly.

The moment devastated Carter, who blamed himself, and Rip, who tried to shoulder responsibility. But the truth was clear: no one was at fault. Colby died the most ordinary kind of cowboy death—quick, brutal, and heartbreakingly unglamorous.

---

Why His Death Stings So Much

John Dutton and Sarah Atwood had made countless enemies, their deaths serving as poetic justice for bloody histories. Colby’s was different.

He was loyal, dependable, and committed to the ranch—not for power, but for belonging. He wasn’t gunned down in a feud or caught in a conspiracy. Instead, he died in an everyday tragedy that underscored the danger of cowboy life.

As Teeter put it:

“He was a cowboy. Suffering’s the job.”

---

The Creative Choice Behind Colby’s Death

Denim Richards (Colby) and executive producer Christina Voros explained the reasoning behind the shocking turn.

• Richards told Entertainment Weekly:
  “I feel like this season, [creator] Taylor Sheridan is really emphasizing the realities of cowboy life… These things do happen, so I do think that there’s that element where I think it is about really wanting to emphasize that this is a reality.”

• Voros told The Hollywood Reporter:
  “In a season where there are all these twists and turns and dark forces and giant narrative swings, Colby’s death is so powerful because it’s so simple… It didn’t happen because someone was out to get him. He was trying to protect Carter, and it was a freak accident.”

Richards confirmed that the decision wasn’t his—he was told back in May his character would be written off.

---

Why Colby’s Death Matters

Colby’s demise serves as a reminder that on Yellowstone, not all tragedies come from assassins, plots, or revenge. Sometimes, the danger lies in the unpredictable nature of the job itself.

His grounded, ordinary death balances the show’s more sensational storylines, reinforcing Sheridan’s vision of Yellowstone as a brutal, unforgiving portrait of cowboy life.